Flip Ultra HD
Basic Features: The Flip UltraHD camcorder combines Flip Video's signature shoot-and-share simplicity with the power of vivid, vibrant HD video. With 120 minutes of record time, you'll never miss another minute again. And because of UltraHD's pocket-sized portability, you'll truly be able to capture HD video anytime, anywhere.
The Good: The Flip Ultra HD is a great all round video camera. It performs fantastically on a bright sunny day, capturing details well and with its stellar 50 frames per second – panning was smooth and focused. The size of the Ultra HD has got to be its biggest selling point – it’s a tiny device that fits in most pockets. Connection to PC or Mac is also a breeze and the included software is fantastic.
The Bad: One of the biggest differentiators between the Flip and other pricier cameras is the lens. While the Ultra HD performs fantastically in bright daylight, ambient lighting causes a few issues, the video comes out a little noisy and colours are dim and yellowed. Also, as the zoom is digital only so images lose quality the further in you go.
The Bottom Line: I think that this is ideal for a student film maker because then they will be able to make decent quality videos for youtube and they will also be able to create high-definition movies. The Flip Ultra HD is very reliable and brilliant value for money even if you can't afford an expensive one. With high frame rates and good quality image stabilisation it’s definitely the best Flip to date.
Rating: Overall, I would give it a 3.5 out of 5 just because of the poor video quality.
Image:
Sony HDR-CX11SE
Basic Features: Sony's impressive new HDR-CX11 camcorder is further proof that the Mpeg-4/H.264-based high-definition camcorder format is now the most affordable route to HD home video. Superb video and still image quality, elegant looks and advanced features. Full HD recording on Memory Stick™, Carl Zeiss Vario-Sonnar T* lens, 5.1 surround sound, Face Detection and Smile Shutter.
The Good: The dial on the front of the camera offers manual control over focus and exposure. This is a very useful facility, although the touch screen operation is just as quick and effective. Other notable features include Face Detection and Smile Shutter. This is useful when shooting in the CX11's stills mode in that the camera will detect when the subject is smiling and grab still images at precisely that point. It’s surprisingly well specified considering that this is Sony’s cheapest AVCHD camera. The 1/4in sensor diagonal is typical for the price but the 25x zoom range is impressive.
The Bad: The lack of a mic input and headphone input will encourage some potential buyers to look elsewhere.Those who like to experiment with advanced settings will be disappointed by the lack of progressive scan shooting.
The Bottom Line: Overall, I think that the Sony is the ideal video camera for student film makers because it would make the user feel as if they were creating a blockbuster. The battery liife is slighly better than the Flip by 3 minutes but that 2 minutes could come in very handy.
Rating: 4.1 out of 5 even though the price could exceed to 220 pounds.
Image:
Canon MD205E
Basic Features: The Canon MD205 is a miniDV camcorder with a Wide High Resolution 16:9 system,, Advanced zoom that offers up to 36x the magnification, DIGIC DV image processor for bright and crisp images, new LCD video light for poorly-lighted settings and a new multi-angle remote control for a wider control and flexibility in video production.
The Good: A big, fat 32x zoom doesn’t hurt either, although the on-board electronic stabilisation is no substitute for a real tripod. If people do start sniggering, you could point out the modern 2.7-inch LCD that reverses to illuminate close-ups, and demonstrate its funky digital effects.
The Bad: MiniDV tapes are pricier than memory cards these days, and heavier too – the MD205 weighs in at 380g.
The Bottom Line: A nicely built basic camcorder with excellent sound and good video. I would recommend this to somebody who is buying their first camcorder, and who wants it for home use. It is easy to use and has some more advanced features if you want to experiment. If you plan on doing a lot of recording you will want to buy a spare battery.
Rating: 4.4 out of 5 even though it has a low battery life.
Image:
Overall, I would choose the Canon because it is a reasonable price and you could do quite a lot of practical video making if you are a student. Another reason why I would recommend this video camera to a student film maker is because as it is a fairly small camera, it would still do all of the qualities that wanted to be done by a student film maker.